Every now and then, I stumble across a romance novel that feels like it was written to be devoured in one sitting—coffee mug in hand, blanket pulled up, the kind of book where you tell yourself, “just one more chapter” and suddenly it’s 2 a.m. Ali Hazelwood’s The Love Hypothesis is exactly that kind of story. It’s nerdy, funny, heartwarming, and has that irresistible fake-dating trope that always makes me grin.
But what surprised me most wasn’t just the romance (though the swoon factor is very high). It was how deeply the book captured the struggles of academia—especially for women in STEM—and how those struggles shape the way Olive, the main character, sees herself and her future. This is a rom-com that sneaks in some serious themes while keeping you laughing, blushing, and rooting for love the whole way through.
The Story: Fake Dating, Real Feelings
Olive Smith is a PhD candidate in biology who’s just trying to survive grad school. She doesn’t believe in lasting relationships, but she tells her best friend she’s seeing someone to avoid awkward questions. And because life loves chaos, she has to prove it—on the spot. So she kisses the first guy she sees in the hallway. Unfortunately (or fortunately?), that guy happens to be Adam Carlsen: the broody, terrifying, ridiculously brilliant professor who’s rumored to be the meanest in the department.
To Olive’s shock, Adam agrees to keep up the fake dating act. From there, we get conferences, lab drama, and more than a few moments where Olive has to confront how “fake” their chemistry really is. And yes, it’s predictable—you can see where it’s going from a mile away—but that’s part of the fun. Like a comforting rom-com movie you’ve watched a dozen times, you don’t read this book to be surprised. You read it for the warmth, the banter, and the giddy anticipation of how it all unfolds.
Why It Works So Well
1. The STEM setting feels real.
Hazelwood herself has a background in neuroscience, and it shows. The labs, the conferences, the endless pressure of grant writing—it’s not just a backdrop. It’s Olive’s world, and it shapes everything about how she thinks and behaves. As someone who loves when books give me a peek into different corners of life, I appreciated the detail. It made the romance feel grounded, not just floating in rom-com land.
2. Olive and Adam’s dynamic is pure comfort reading.
Their personalities balance each other perfectly: Olive is anxious, hopeful, and a little chaotic, while Adam is guarded, blunt, and very much the grumpy to her sunshine. Their banter is sharp but never mean, and their gradual softening toward each other makes the payoff so satisfying. I’m a sucker for the “secretly soft” grump trope, and Adam delivers in spades.
3. Imposter syndrome at the heart of it.
What really struck me was Olive’s constant self-doubt. She’s smart, hardworking, and clearly talented, yet she spends most of the book convincing herself she’s not enough. That’s such a real and painful thing for so many people in high-pressure environments—especially women in male-dominated fields. It can feel repetitive at times, but honestly, imposter syndrome is repetitive. It creeps back in every time you take a step forward. The book doesn’t shy away from that.
A Few Things That Didn’t Land
Of course, no book is perfect. If you’ve read a lot of romances, you’ll recognize the tropes: fake dating, forced proximity, miscommunication. Some readers might wish for more originality. But for me, that was part of the charm—it was a warm blanket of familiar tropes, written with enough wit and heart to feel fresh.
Also, Adam’s character sometimes leans a little too perfect. Yes, he’s broody and intimidating on the outside, but once the romance kicks in, he’s endlessly supportive, protective, and adoring. It’s swoony, but maybe a touch unrealistic. Then again… sometimes unrealistic is exactly what you want from a romance.
Final Thoughts: Why This Book Stuck With Me
When I finished The Love Hypothesis, I couldn’t stop smiling. It’s one of those books that makes you want to text a friend immediately and say, “You have to read this.” It gave me the cozy satisfaction of watching a good rom-com, but also left me thinking about the bigger themes woven in—what it means to carve out space for yourself in a competitive environment, how vulnerability and courage often go hand in hand, and how love, no matter how improbable, can sneak up on you in the most unexpected places.
Hazelwood has since written more STEM-centered romances, but this one set the tone. It’s lighthearted and tropey in the best way, but it also knows how to dig deeper. For me, it wasn’t just about Olive and Adam—it was about the reminder that even the most data-driven, rational people can’t always quantify the messy, wonderful experiment that is love.
✨ My Rating: 4.5/5 stars. Perfect for when you need something funny, nerdy, slightly smutty, and heartwarming, with just the right mix of predictable and surprising.
Cups & Curiosity 
Leave a comment